New ‘Green’ Milk Jugs Not Cutting it with Consumers
July 11, 2008 · Print This Article
So, apparently green milk jugs kind of suck. At least, that’s according to the Wal-Mart and Costco shoppers who have purchased the newly redesigned gallon jugs and complain about how hard they are to pour. These new jugs have been introduced because they’re cheaper to ship, better for the environment, cost less and provide fresher milk to the store. The new shape makes the jugs stackable and eliminates the need for crates. Indentations in the plastic give the jugs structural support.
From The New York Times, via Treehugger:
The jugs have no real spout, and their unorthodox shape makes consumers feel like novices at the simple task of pouring a glass of milk.
“I hate it,” said Lisa DeHoff, a cafe owner shopping in a Sam’s Club here.
“It spills everywhere,” said Amy Wise, a homemaker.
“It’s very hard for kids to pour,” said Lee Morris, who was shopping for her grandchildren.
Eco-Fail – not because it’s not innovative or is a bad idea, but because this is the sort of thing that turns off the millions of Wal-Mart shoppers from ‘green’ products and ideas. I mean, great way to turn the Wal-Mart set green – take away their easy pouring milk jugs and give them something to complain about, especially in this nation of resistance to change. They’re more than likely not going to care if the jugs help the environment if they can’t even pour milk into a bowl of cereal without spilling it.
A commenter on the Treehugger post suggested some kind of reusable accessory – stainless steel, perhaps – that mounts onto the jug to make it easier to pour. Great idea, but would Wal-Mart shoppers really go for that? They want simple, cheap and fast. Perhaps another redesign is in the cards – one that’s more practical for everyday use.
Link [The New York Times] via [Treehugger] via [Bag of Nothing]
Photo credit: David Maxwell for the New York Times
Related Posts:
Who Says Solar Panels Have to be Ugly?New Vivavi Eco-Friendly Furniture Store at Riverhouse in NYC
A Green Wal-Mart? Not So Fast…
Get a DIY Flat-Pack Home Delivered and Have an Attractive Cabin in Two Days
Wal-Mart CEO is a Master of the Obvious: Our Company is Not Green
Gaaaahh, I spill on myself! Gaaaahhhh. No change. Oooooogg.
Fits perfectly in my fridge door. My 6 year old can pour it. As I previously suggested…Idiots.
I tried the new carton. It fits nicely in the fridge. It seems a bit awkward to use and everytime I poured myself some milk I spilled some. I think the carton needs more of a spout opening. I’ve been pouring milk for over 50 years so it isn’t like I’m new at it.
Geez, they already fixed this issue with liquid detergents. Just add an interior spout. Am I missing something? Why throw out a perfectly good idea because they can’t come up with a spout?